Zac Efron may have the ability to make 90% of girls age 10-16 swoon, but his perception is a little off when it comes to distinguishing the difference between cupcakes and canine treats.

Girlfriend Vanessa Hudgens was reportedly shocked when she realized a batch of gourmet dog desserts she’d purchased for pup Shadow had been devoured by Zac instead.

Star Magazine writes:

“Vanessa left them on the counter, and Zac ate a few. Zac didn’t care. He said that they were good, if a little bland.”