Jake Gyllenhaal sure isn’t doing much to kill those rumors about his sexuality. There are whispers of a Jake Gyllenhaal Tobey Maguire feud brewing on the set of their latest film, Brothers. Two of Hollywood’s hottest men are fighting over who gets exclusive rights over the set’s lone makeup artist.

“They each want their own retoucher, but the producers don’t think it’s necessary and don’t see why they can’t share,” an on-set source tells Star Magazine.

“Tobey is holding out for his own person, while Jake said he needs his artist so badly he’ll let her stay with him during the shoot.”