Tara Reid’s already been the victim of plastic surgery gone haywire, but some of the blonde’s most devoted fans (yes, she still has fans) want her to get butchered again-this time by legendary dream slayer Freddy Krueger. Fans of the troubled actress have begun an online petition to get the American Pie star a role in the upcoming remake of A Nightmare on Elm Street remake.

“She is a very talented and intelligent actor,” the petition reads. “We feel a major role in a major film will help revive her acting career. We feel she would be a truly great addition to the cast.”