On Monday night’s Season Finale of The Hills, it was revealed that Spencer Pratt and Heidi Montag aren’t really newlyweds because the pair have yet to legalize their quickie Mexican wedding.

The Hills stars eloped in a Mexican wedding ceremony that was not legally binding on November 19, but when the time came to make things official on last night’s show, Spencer got cold-feet and had a change of heart.

“I feel like we’re doing something sneaky and shady. I just want to give you the wedding of your dreams that you have been talking about for three years.”