Rumer Willis has landed her first magazine cover. And so what if it’s on the front of the free insert that comes along with the Sunday New York Post!

Rumer tells Page Six Magazine she was shocked to be named one of People Magazine’s 100 Most Beautiful People earlier this year: “After being compared to Jay Leno for so long, you don’t think of yourself in that way.”

Rumer makes her acting debut in The House Bunny, in theaters later this month.