Songbird Mariah Carey is slated to record a cover of “I Want to Know What Love Is,” the enduring 1984 ballad from British-American rock band Foreigner.

The track is being toted as a potential single for Madame Butterfly’s latest album due out later this year–much to the chagrin of Latin salsa star Marc Anthony, who had been hoping to purchase the rights to the song for a remake of his own.