Lindsay Lohan has once again sparked rumors that she is dating reality TV star Brody Jenner after the two were spotted “all over each other” as they partied together at two NYC nightclubs, the Beatrice Inn and The Box, on Friday January 25th.

“She likes him. It’s early, but they are more than friends. He seems to like her back. They’re actually sweet together, it would be nice if she kept him around,” a spy reveals to People.