Eastwick star Lindsay Price and How I Met Your Mother’s Josh Radnor are calling it quits, Life & Style reports.

“She ended it,” an insider said. “They have different lifestyles. He’s a bit of a homebody, while she likes to go out and have fun.”

Radnor, 35, and Price, 32, first met on the set of his CBS comedy in 2007 and began dating a year and a half later.