Cynthia Rodriguez believes this week’s reports of a sexual relationship between her basball star husband and music legend Madonna. C-Rod doesn’t quite buy Madge’s denials of a clandestine affair with Yankees third baseman Alex Rodriguez, a spywitness tattled to Us Weekly on Thursday.

“She doesn’t believe they are just friends…Something deeply suspicious is happening,” the source adds. “Cynthia did leave because she is sure this is all true.”