Even with numerous titles seemingly solidifying Brad Pitt’s status as one of the best looking men in Hollywood, not everyone believes the award-winning actor is aging gracefully-as one guest so eloquently pointed out at HBO’s Golden Globes Afterparty on Sunday night.

“Brad was enjoying a cocktail and chatting with friends at party when this woman, who was clearly drunk, approached him. She went on and on about how the aging make-up in The Curious Case Of Benjamin Button made him look ‘ugly as a dog,’” a source at the Beverly Hills Hilton giggled in Britain’s Daily Mail on Tuesday.

In the movie based on a famous short story by F. Scott Fitzgerald, Brad plays a man who ages backwards, therefore he spends much of the film with prosthetics on his face to make him look older.

“Brad listened politely and explained that the make-up was essential to telling the story properly,” a source at the Beverly Hills Hilton giggled in Britain’s Daily Mail on Tuesday.

“The woman finally piped down for a moment, then looked closely at Brad’s face. She then said, ‘And you should definitely shave that goatee because it looks just horrible’, before marching off. Brad’s buddies cracked up laughing.”