Newlywed actress Alyssa Milano and actor Isaiah Mustafa — the shirtless beefcake affectionately known simply as “The Old Spice Guy” — have spent the latter part of the week playing footsies with one another from opposite ends of the Twitterverse.

Pulling a stunt snatched straight from one of Mustafa’s signature deordorant ads, Alyssa’s gotten mostly naked in her own bathroom and recorded a challenge to Mr. Old Spice. If he wants to take their relationship to the next level, he’ll have to pony up $100k to the National Wildlife Federation’s Gulf Oil Spill Restoration Fund.

Is he man enough?